Center for Policy Analysis on Trade and Health - CPATH
Campaign: Public Health Voice in Trade Policy
Home
About CPATH - Overview
Support CPATH!
Contact Us
Campaign: Public Health Voice in Trade Policy
Recent News: Korea; Peru; Public Health Objectives
Global Trade Events at APHA November 2007
Thailand's Compulsory Licenses for Medicines
Globalization and Health Resource Center - Overview
Key Trade Agreements - CPATH Analysis and Commentary
Key Issues
CPATH Publications
Related Resources
CPATH Presentations
CPATH at US Social Forum 2007
Monterey Forum 2005
FTAA Forum
Public Health Summary Statements on Free Trade Agreements
Resolutions
Sign-On Statements
More About CPATH

CPATH Responds to NY Times: Health Key to Trade and Properity

12/27/07 NY Times, CPATH response to "Trade and Prosperity" editorial:

To the Editor:

Current trade agreements preclude and sometimes reverse the very safety net you propose to ameliorate their damage, as new Congressional leaders recognize. Trade pacts undermine access to affordable medicines and offer new levers of power to the drug, tobacco, alcohol, health care and processed food industries. These industries dominate United States federal trade advisory committees and influence trade policy to promote the bottom line over health.

The public, the candidates and The Times are right to call for affordable health care. We also need a new, sustainable trade model that does not destabilize public health benefits where they exist or are emerging among our trading partners. These are the genuine keys to prosperity.

Ellen R. Shaffer
San Francisco, Dec. 23, 2007
The writer is co-director of the Center for Policy Analysis on Trade and Health.

To see the original editorial, and excelllent responses by CPATH, Tony Avirgan of EPI and others:

Click Here to download file

Campaign for Public Health Representation in Trade Policy

 

CPATH is coordinating the call by U.S. health organizations to include advocates for the public’s health on the U.S. Trade Representative's Advisory Committees, and to open Committee meetings to public scrutiny. Committee members enjoy significant influence on trade policy, according to a report by the Government Accountability Office.  Committees currently include representatives of the pharmaceutical, tobacco, health insurance, alcohol and processed food industries.  The Committees are legally required to present fairly balanced views on trade negotiations. There are no representatives of organizations concerned with the effects of international trade on health.

 

Many members of Congress strongly support the goal of public health representation in trade policy. 

 

GAO: U.S. Trade Policy Neglects Public Health

On 10/30/07, Rep. Henry A. Waxman and Sen. Edward M. Kennedy released a GAO report which finds that U.S. trade policy under the Bush Administration has neglected public health and the Doha Declaration, which affirms the right of WTO members to “promote access to medicines for all.”
 
Formal public health input into trade policy from the public health community has been limited, according to the GAO.  U.S.T.R. receives counsel on specific sectors and issues from fourteen “trade advisory committees.”  Most have no public health representation.

Click here for GAO Report

Van Hollen/Waxman Bill Calls for Public Health Trade Advisors - Aug. 2007
 
Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) has introduced HR 3204, to expand public health representation on trade advisory committees, and assure an active role for Congress and the public in setting trade policy.  Rep. Henry Waxman is an original co-sponsor.  CPATH will be working with allies in the coming months to build awareness of this important bill.  Please contact CPATH if you'd like to help.

Click here for Summary of HR 3204

Click here for Full Text of HR 3204

Why USTR Must Take Action to Represent Public Health on U.S. Trade Advisory Committees:   A Brief Trade and Health Timeline, 1948-2006       June 16, 2006

click here for Timetable June 2006

Six key Senators and 9 Congressional Representatives urge the USTR to represent public health in trade negotiations.

click here for letter from key Senators and House Reps

Notes from Meeting of Public Health Organizations and Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR)
June 12, 2006


Summary: Public health organizations and members of Congress have asserted public health’s strong interest in serving on trade advisory committees that influence US trade policies. The USTR’s office has agreed that public health has a legitimate claim to be represented. On December 16, 2005, the Department of Commerce and USTR posted a Federal Register announcement seeking public health nominees to Industry Trade Advisory Committees (ITACs) 3 (Chemicals, Pharmaceuticals, Health/Science Products & Services) and 15 (Intellectual Property).


To date, no nominees have been selected. The USTR has not responded to reasonable requests from public health groups for deadlines on appointments. During that time, ITAC 3 has established a subcommittee on pharmaceuticals and intellectual property, which continues to meet without public health representation.

Read a report of the meeting

HEALTH GROUPS CALL FOR REPRESENTATION  May 2, 2005
Nine national health organizations called on the U.S. Trade Representative and Secretary of Commerce to include advocates for the public's health on its Advisory Committees, and to open Committee meetings to public scrutiny.
 

The organizations are: CPATH, American College of Preventive Medicine, American Public Health Association, American Nurses Association, California Conference of Local Health Officers, Doctors for Global Health, National Association of Community Health Centers, Physicians for Human Rights, and Physicians for Social Responsibility.

click here for Letter Requesting Public Health Representation, May 2, 2005

click here for Press Release May 2, 2005

CPATH REPORT: INTERNATIONAL TRADE ADVISORY COMMITTEES WARRANTING PUBLIC HEALTH AND HEALTH CARE REPRESENTATION May 2, 2005

CPATH analyzes United States trade advisory committees which currently lack and warrant public health and health care and health care representation. Statements from advisory committee reports demonstrate that they are of interest to and directly affect the work of the Public Health and Health Care community.

click here for full report

USTR Response to Request for Public Health Representation June 2005

CPATH Briefing Paper: International Trade Advisory Committee System Should Include Public Health Representation, September, 2004.

click here for full report

On December 14, 2005, US health groups announce a federal suit against the US Government calling for representation on trade policy advisory committees.

click here for Press Release December 14, 2005

USTR response to notice of intent to sue. 12-05

  TRADE ADVISORY
  COMMITTEES
  BIG BUSINESS:             42
  PUBLIC HEALTH:            0

Pharma
20
Public Health
0
Tobacco
  7
Public Health
0
Alcohol
  6
Public Health
0
Food
  5
Public Health
0
Health Insurance
  4
Public Health
0

TOTAL BIG BUSINESS

42

TOTAL PUBLIC HEALTH

0

The U. S. Trade Advisory Committees are legally required to represent a fair balance of interests.  The table above shows the reported breakdown of members prior to CPATH's work to promote public health representation.

 

Since 2005, as a result of CPATH’s Campaign for Public Health Accountability, the USTR has appointed a tobacco control representative to a key Advisory Committee, on Tobacco, Cotton and Peanuts, and a public health professional to the Advisoy Committee on Pharmaceuticals, reflected in the table below. 

  TRADE ADVISORY
  COMMITTEES
  BIG BUSINESS:             42
  PUBLIC HEALTH:           3

Pharma
20
Public Health
2
Tobacco
  7
Public Health
1
Alcohol
  6
Public Health
0
Food
  5
Public Health
0
Health Insurance
  4
Public Health
0
TOTAL BIG BUSINESS
42
Public Health
3

To sign up or volunteer for an event, see our "Contact Us" page.

Bringing a Public Health Voice to Global Trade and Sustainable Development
CPATH
Ellen R. Shaffer and Joe Brenner, Co-Directors
98 Seal Rock Drive, San Francisco, CA 94121
phone 415-933-6204  fax 415-831-4091